How to Design a Winning Menu of Tasting Experiences

Your tasting menu is more than just a list of options—it’s your invitation to every type of wine consumer who walks through your door. Too often, tasting rooms rely on a single experience or focus heavily on large groups, unintentionally closing the door to smaller parties or guests looking for something different.

The perfect tasting menu is designed with variety, accessibility, and guest expectations in mind. Here’s how to create one that captures the widest range of wine lovers.

Step 1: Stay Visible to Small Groups

Most visitors to wine country are couples or small groups of friends. If your experiences only cater to groups of six or more, you’ll disappear from their CellarPass searches. Always include tastings that are available for parties of 2–4 so you’re front and center when the majority of consumers are browsing.

Step 2: Offer a Range of Experiences

Wine consumers come with different goals—some want casual fun, others want education, and some are looking for a special occasion. To meet those needs, design a tasting menu with at least four different types of experiences:

1. Casual Tasting (Drop-In or Bar Style) – Affordable, approachable, and great for first-time visitors.
2. Seated Flight – A guided, relaxed experience ideal for those who want to learn more about your wines.
3. Educational Experience – Vineyard tours, blending classes, or cellar walkthroughs for the curious and engaged.
4. Premium or Reserve Tasting – Exclusive, intimate, and elevated for collectors or guests celebrating something special.

This structure ensures you’re connecting with everyone—from the social sipper to the serious collector.

Step 3: Schedule Smartly

Not every experience has to run every day. Use availability to your advantage:

• Weekends → Premium, reserve, and formal seated tastings.
• Weekdays → Casual, educational, and affordable tastings when traffic is lighter.

This helps you maximize staff efficiency while also meeting guests where they are in the week.

Step 4: Use Pricing to Attract and Convert

Price-sensitive doesn’t mean unprofitable. Offering sub-$20 tastings Tuesday through Thursday is a great way to fill slower days. Guests may start budget-conscious, but if they find a wine they love, that $20 entry point can lead to bottle sales, case purchases, or even wine club memberships.

Step 5: Map the Guest Journey

Your tasting menu should guide guests naturally from discovery to loyalty:

• Casual tastings bring new visitors in the door.
• Guided and educational experiences deepen their connection to your wines.
• Premium experiences encourage club sign-ups and collector-level purchases.

Think of your menu not as separate items, but as stepping stones in a long-term relationship.

Step 6: Refresh Regularly

Guest expectations change with the seasons—and so does your wine program. Review your tasting menu quarterly to make sure your offerings are fresh, relevant, and aligned with your current goals.

The Takeaway

The perfect tasting menu isn’t about offering everything—it’s about offering the right mix. By balancing casual and premium, educational and approachable, weekday and weekend, you’ll create an experience that appeals to the widest range of wine consumers while boosting bookings, sales, and loyalty.

‍